Jersey Boys Musical vs Jersey Boys Film by Clint Eastwood.

Four Seasons Tribute Frankie's Guys Laughing
As the worlds, number one Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons Tribute act we’re obviously huge fans of the hit musical Jersey Boys, but how does it compare to the 2014 movie release.

‘Movie adaptations and remakes, of both books and musicals, often deviate from the source material in varying degrees and this is often one of the main sources of debate and sometimes their success or failure.

Play it safe and you could risk losing your audience’s attention, change it up too much and the die-hard fans will no doubt not be happy. It certainly seems a tough balance to get right and even as Four Seasons mega fans, we’re not entirely sure about this one.

Probably the world’s most successful Musical to movie adaptations was the 2014 release of Les Misérables. With a star studded cast, including Hugh Jackman, Russel Crowe & Anne Hathaway the movie was directed by Cameron Machinto and has grossed over $441 million worldwide.

On the other hand, Cats – The Musical was recently adapted into a movie in 2019 and was reviewed by critics and audience members as one of the worst adaptions of all time, with stars of the film seeming to agree.


Jersey Boys Movie by Clint Eastwood

The Jersey Boys movie, from 2014, was directed by Clint Eastwood and starred Vincent Piazza as Tommy DeVito and John Lloyd Young as Frankie Valli is another musical to movie adaptations that received mixed reviews.

However, unlike many book adaptations, the criticisms do not appear to be from the musical being changed too much, and the musical itself is often regarded as being an accurate portrayal of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons.

With Frankie Valli previously stating:

“One of the things I learned really quickly was that it was really important if they were going to do a story about your life … at least 98 percent of it had to be the real truth,”


Jersey Boys Movie Accuracy

The movie was faithful to the musical in many ways and it doesn’t stray far from the true story on which it’s based. Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice, who wrote the musical, also wrote the film’s screenplay and Frankie Vialli was an executive producer.

In fact, some critics argue that the movie doesn’t stand out as anything special.


Mixed Reactions

Unfortunately many critics felt the movie lacked the electric excitement of the musical with it only achieving 55 on Metascore. As for audience opinion, as always with movies, these range from exceptional to awful.

While the movie may not have achieved the success of the West End and Broadway Musical, for fans of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons it certainly was a treat to have the groups incredible back story brought to the silver screen and reaching new audiences.


Theatre Tour

Talking of theatre, it’s been an awful year for those of us in the industry and for live music fans the world over. With 90% of our 2020 tour being rescheduled for 2021. (Check out our 2021 TOUR DATES)

But fear not, live music is most certainly coming back and if you love the music of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons don’t forget to check out our show; Frankie’s Guys.

Jersey Boys Tribute Frankie's Guys on stage

We’ve been touring the world for the last six years and have recently won the award-winning for London’s Best Tribute 2019 & 2020 four our Jersey Boys Tribute Show.

The show features four of London’s leading men, several of whom have toured with the global smash hit musical Jersey Boys. Charming, cheeky and extremely charismatic, alongside our live band we perform timeless classics such as ‘Big Girls Don’t Cry’, ‘Walk Like A Man’, ‘Sherry’, ‘December ’63’, and many more. (CLICK HERE to view our full set list)

Frankie’s Guys: A Celebration of Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons Promotional Video

Private Bookings For Weddings & Parties

Alternatively, Frankie’s Guys are available for weddings and private parties, where they are happy to tailor their recommended setlist to suit your needs.

Jersey Boys Tribute Frankie's Guys partying with wedding guests

Featuring slick choreography & incredible vocals, this cheeky foursome know exactly how to get the party started. With the perfect mix off charm, charisma and non-stop banter, they’re sure to leave you singing “Oh What a Night!” and have your guests “Beggin” for more.

You can find hundreds of FIVE STAR fan reviews by clicking HERE.

If you’re thinking of booking a band for your special event or occasion don’t forget to also check out our TOP 10 TIPS FOR BOOKING WEDDING ENTERTAINMENT.

Get in touch today for a FREE QUOTE or call 01603 949 999

Like this article?

Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Share on Twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on Linkdin
Share on pinterest
Share on Pinterest

Leave a comment